Product: t.amp E800 Pro PA Amplifier
Manufacturer: t.amp (Thomann Music Store) - made in China
Approx. price: 139 € (YMMV)
Reviewer: Geoff Husband - firstname.lastname@example.org - TNT France
Reviewed: May 2012
I sing in a music school rock-band. We do old-person's-rock-covers and generally have a good time, we're dreadful as you can imagine. We also inevitably buy gear on a budget and as vocalist I was delegated to chase up a new PA amp for the group.
With teenage son's into guitars and drums I'm used to sending hard-earned cash to Thomann – the biggest of all the European music equipment companies, and so it's generally a first port of call for most 'pro' music gear.
It took but a moment to drill down onto the appropriate section of the website, find something cheap and cheerful and hit the 'buy' button. As always with Thomann the thing arrived in under a week so I dug it out to play with and was hit very quickly by the thought that this little amp might, just might be worth plugging into my hi-fi for a giggle.
139 euro. 12 kg. 500 watt per channel into 4ohms, 370 into 8 ohms (and a vid I found on youtube showed the older less-powerful version of the amp pumping a continuous 595 watts into a 4 ohm load so those figures are conservative) – 800 watt bridged mode into 8 ohm.
Now tell me you wouldn't have stuck it into your system just to see:-)
This thing is so different from hi-fi gear that it's impossible to give any valued judgment, so I'm just going to write down the bare facts as I uncovered them.
First it is well packed, and lifting its not inconsiderable weight and taking off the plastic bag you are immediately struck by its battleship build. It's a standard 19” rack mount and the case is made of a series of steel plates bolted together. You could stand on it without damage... no you could jump on it. It's a million miles from the thin steel sheet wrap, screwed together with a plastic face plate you'd expect from a mass-produced hi-fi amp of the same cost.
On the front are two volume controls, one for each channel so if you are running a one-source system this power amp will suffice and of course in the hi-fi world double volume controls are very 'high-end'... They are a bit plastic and small but what the hell. There are also LED indicators to provide clipping warning, source connection, power, bridge mode, protection shut-down etc but it's all very discrete. The face plate has the t.amp E800 logo, but it's pretty tastefully done and though no beauty there's no real give-away to the fact that it's come from the 'dark-side' beyond the cooling vents along the front – something you don't see on hi-fi amps.
Round the back is a very interesting set of toys – decent quality speaker binding posts are coupled with Speakon outputs (which are the pro standard) – and there are both balanced and jack-plug inputs for signal. Sadly no phono plug input, but many sources/preamps now have balanced outputs, and failing that there are always mixed cables/converters etc. There are also switches to change from stereo, to bridged, to mono, and for clipping protection. There's also a ground lift, and most important (see below) one for sensitivity. The switches are tiny little things, but then, like the DIP switches used on many hi-fi's it's something you'll set once and forget.
So all in all a very comprehensively equipped little power amplifier.
So then I undid the (I seem to remember 10) machine screws (not self-tappers) to lift the lid and the pictures below will show what I found inside.
Just look at it! That hulking great toroid – its rating isn't marked but it's going to be 600 VA at a guess and that is 1000 Euro hi-fi amp territory, and many much more expensive amps will make do with less. A commercial hi-fi amp of this price would have something around 100VA. Of course that says nothing of its quality, but it's not going to be short on current that's for sure.
Another glance and it's blindingly obvious even to my ignorant eyes that it's fully dual mono-from transformer to speaker outputs, the amplifier boards being totally separate (though strangely not totally symmetrical) and the power supply board split with 20,000 uF of reserve capacitors a side. There are 6 power transistors a side and lots of other little shiny surface mount bits I don't understand – no doubt those of you who understand these things will be able to work it out, those, like me, who can't don't need to bother. But the layout is neat, the mains input is filtered, it all looks very professional and well made.
But this is a near-kW amp so where are the massive heat-sinks? Well the first thing is to be realistic. This isn't going to be a purist class-A amp. That hugely inefficient but very popular configuration would be a waste of time for a pro amp, and there are a lot of well regarded high-end amps that abandon it for class-B (Naim for example). Thus it's going to produce less heat than some, but even then we're talking about a huge power output. The solution is obvious – there are pretty hefty heat sinks running front to back in the case, with one for each bank of power transistors, but lurking at the back are two cooling fans – one for each channel. That's why the front of the case is slotted – and these two fans pump a lot of air over those cooling fins. Not only does that mean that the amp runs stone cold unless pushed way beyond any domestic application (when I used it hard as a PA amp it still stayed cool) it also means that placement isn't critical – as long as some air can circulate (and that means anything but a sealed box) it'll be OK and won't set your house on fire...
What I'm trying to say is that you will not see anything remotely like this layout and component count, on anything remotely at this price point from the hi-fi world. Hell's teeth the toroid alone would cost you over 50 Euro.
So it's built like a tank, well protected (so bullet proof) – so no risk of shorting or zero-load damage, 3-year guarantee and even reasonable to look at. So how is it done. Well obviously it's going to be made in millions in some Chinese factory. The parts are all no-name, 20,000 uF reserve a side is a hell of a lot for an amp of that price but not much for a 1000 W amp. It's sold direct by Thomann so no middle-man. It's designed primarily to pump current not to catch the sound of resin-on-bow. But even taking all this into consideration I'm utterly stunned by what you get for the money – it just looks like there is an order of magnitude difference in value compared to the hi-fi world...
So for the sake of the hi-fi industry it better sound pretty crap or we are going have to do some serious thinking back at TNT Towers...
Anyway I plugged the thing into a scratch system of the Opera M15 Horns - efficient but a difficult load – but most important of all, fitted with drivers capable of withstanding a 'pop' from a few hundred Watts – no way was this monster going to fry my Polaris horns! Front-end was the Opera Droplet CD player which has a direct balanced output.
So a 139 Euro power amp fronting a 10,000 Euro system:-)
To make it's like easier (irony alert) I compared it directly to the 4000 Euro Jungson JA-99D, a 100W class-A monster that dwarfed the t.amp.
Well it's silent in output, but the fans do make a noise, not much more than the fan on the 8000 Euro SQF valve amp, but in some positions that could be irritating. Thankfully you could happily put the amp in a cupboard and shut the door – it wouldn't overheat...
As the Opera doesn't have a variable output I used the two controls on the t.amp, though if a pre-amp was used it would be better to put these at max to bypass them as much as possible – this isn't just for this amp, but any amp with a variable output.
And so I dropped Led Zep 1 into the maw of the Opera and sat back – and for the moment the hi-fi industry can rest comfortably on its laurels. The sound was very forward – little bass to speak of and the treble grainier than I could live with.
But to be fair the CD player (valve remember) was stone cold – the amp new and equally frigid and the speakers hadn't been used for two months.
So I left a CD on in the music room and left it all to warm up.
OK... It's very far from perfect. Firstly it's quite forward sounding and has a tendency to treble grain – early CD's can sound like 8-bit at times and there's a tendency for cymbals to go tiss tiss rather than the more complex tone and decay the Jungson produced... But a lot of this is down to the source, and the fact that the treble/mid horns of the M15's are inevitably very revealing. On smoother CD's and music that edge becomes less apparent, but it's always lurking – not helped by the fact that LOUD! is so easy that you tend to push speakers harder than usual. But overall treble is a bit thin and grainy.
There's also not of the warmth that the Jungson gave – bass was lighter and as with the treble there was little sense of the roundness of a note, the decay of a kick-drum and so on. So bass-light, a bit tuneless and short on body.
In fact in these respects it is extremely reminiscent of a typical cheap transistor integrated of about the same price.
And if that was all then the review would end there – fabulous value because for the price of a cheap integrated 40W amp you get something of battleship built and capable of driving any speaker to any volume you could possibly desire in the domestic situation.
But that isn't all. The first hint of what the amp does especially well was when I put on my bootlegged copy 'Prince – Unreleased Masters' – no you won't find this disc on the web – it's very difficult to get hold of. My copy was given to me by Christophe Cabasse (of Cabasse Speakers) many years ago – he used it in demo's.
Track 5 and 6 are recordings made in a continuous single live-in-the-studio pass in collaboration with NPG drummer Michael Bland and bassist Sonny T. Prince originally intended to give this live CD away free with 1,000 copies of Guitar Player magazine in 1994 but it was stamped on by Prince's record company. It's just the trio playing and direct to mixing desk and on to a DAT tape, not the finest recording medium but effectively direct-to-disc – it's the most 'immediate' electric recording I have.
Track 6 is 'Undertaker' and opens with a lot of swirling phase effects on his guitar. They are there with the Jungson, but with the t.amp Prince's guitar just swirls around the room – it's really exceptional and the sort of thing single-ended valves do so well – going back to the Jungson it all collapsed back into a warm glow between the speakers. What this means is that the t.amp must have a fine control of phase, and the terrific soundstaging confirmed that attribute. In fact it reminded me of the 'other' T-Amp – the little 5W digital wonder... And then there's the bass. Yes it's a bit light and lacking colour, but boy is it fast with the shock wave hitting you when the kick-drum doubles up. This unedited studio recording also catches little snatches of conversation in the background sometimes – no other amp has bettered this sort of detail. This is all helped by the very low noise floor and the overall dry presentation.
Putting on more mainstream stuff confirms this terrific detail in the midrange, and again if there is a soundstage on the record the t.amp E800 will pull it off. I have to say that this was utterly unexpected.
Of course all of this was done with the amp cruising without ever drawing breath – with speakers needing only a handful of Watts to go loud the t.amp was hardly at tick-over. The downside of this was that the range of volume control was a bit limited, the variable sensitivity helped, but even then you are never going to get the pots much past 12 o'clock without hearing-damage. But the advantage of this is that your choice of speakers is totally open – 2 ohm load? - low 80's dbl sensitivity – gimmi a break, with 500+ Watts to play with who cares. If you want to go bonkers you could buy two and have a two kilowatt pair...
But of course speaker matching is absolutely critical. That hard, grainy treble is tough to live with with something using a compression driver – you want something smooth as silk and maybe even a bit rolled off. Likewise you want to look for a speaker with plenty of bass and if possible a natural warmth. Unfortunately here I ran into a roadblock because as my systems all run Valves or Class A I've tended to collect the most revealing and detailed speakers and these are precisely what you must avoid if you are to get the best from the t.amp. It's also – dare I say it? – better with vinyl than CD.
You must also beware of the crushing power this amp brings to the party (literally). People with a budget of under 150 Euro are not generally used to almost endless power and rest assured the T-Amp has the power to drive almost any domestic speaker to destruction without breaking sweat. At a party the temptation is to keep winding up that volume. Usually such behavior risks damaging speakers as an amp overdrives and pumps DC into a driver – something you can hear easily. The T-Amp will just go on driving cleanly until you start hearing the 'crack' of a bass-mid driver hitting the bump stops, or a tweeter just melts its coil. For example BBC monitor speakers, Rogers et al would be ideal, but being inefficient you will want to crank the volume up to revel in new levels of sound, but you'll cook them in seconds if you do. You have been warned – and remember that though you can buy new speakers, you can't buy new ears...
Well I'm a bit taken aback. In the original Tripath T-Amp we had an amplifier costing less than 50 Euro in a tiny plastic box that produces a wonderful clear, detailed, but slightly forward and bass-light sound. It changed the face of budget hi-fi but at the cost of accommodating its pitiful output. The T-Amp E800 is like something from another planet in comparison. Its design is utterly conventional (I believe based on an old classic PA amp) and it is made to pump cheap Watts through a PA. But by dint of good layout and massive power supply it does a few things utterly brilliantly and has the ability to drive practically anything. It is an unbalanced product, and I suspect that 'balance' may be one attribute that PA amplifiers have lower on the list of priorities, but even its weaknesses are less than most similarly priced, but puny transistor hi-fi amps.
But it's more than that – whereas the original tripath based T-Amp was a pathetic plastic box with spring-clip terminals and jack-plug input, here you have a flexible, full-sized, well-equipped box that lacks for nothing. The Tripath needed to be reboxed before you did anything to it, and by the time you'd bought a box and terminals and connectors you'd soon be into E800 money. The various 'super T-Amp' clones address this to a point and are the only things that better the E800 in ultimate sound quality for the money, but they are severely limited in other ways and even then the E800 manages to do some things better.
Which brings me to another thought - tweeking. Though the box is well filled there's still plenty of space to upgrade those power caps, it's easy to change wiring and so-on – who knows what 100 Euro of designer components could do (perhaps nothing;-) Personally I would be tempted to either disconnect or place a switch in the path of the fan motors, because in a small room you'll hear their whoosh and you simply do not need to cool the amp at the output levels needed for the domestic environment.
So – to conclude – who is this for? Everybody... If you are looking to buy a cheap integrated forget it – the E800 will trample it in overall sound quality regardless of it's huge build quality and power advantages. Want something as a back-up for your mega-expensive power-amp – well why not? You may even come to prefer it and save a fortune. Going to throw a party – well what else will do the job so well, and you'd be surprised how many friends you will discover when people find out you've a pukka PA amp to lend out. And of course when your teenage son wants to deafen the neighbours don't let him touch your good stuff – just throw him the E800 knowing that whether he shorts the inputs, runs it flat out with the speaker cables disconnected on one side or uses it as a doorstop he isn't going to break it. Surround system? It'll be ideal – buy four and and win the pub 'top-trump' games with your friends and their 10,000 Euro systems. Want to fiddle about doing DIY upgrades? You're not risking a lot. And of course – when you reach your mid-life crisis and find yourself looking for a band so you can pretend to be a young Mick Jagger, you'll find guitarists welcoming you, and your amp, with open arms. And lastly – if all that I've written here is rubbish, and you find yourself with a dog of an amplifier you hate then just send it back within 30 days and Thomann will refund your money. What do you want – blood???
So... what an odd review. Have I by chance stumbled on a jewel of a power-amp that - unique in the world of pro-audio - is perfectly suited to domestic hi-fi? No of course not. There are a hundred similar amps, and many more PA amps that are far, far more expensive. But what I have discovered, and fear, is that the value equation for PA equipment is utterly different from that of the hi-fi world. If this was marketed to the hi-fi fraternity, with a more 'domestic' (but cheaper) case it'd be multiples of the price. Of course it has glaring faults but that doesn't alter the fact that it, and I suspect some of its pro brethren do perform in some areas well beyond their price range. I don't intend to try to fathom out why this is so, but I do – if I can get review samples (though I purchased the E800 it's not something I can afford to do further) I intend to explore the world of 'professional' gear. But just remember - one-hundred-and-thirty-nine-euro...
*When I reviewed the original tripath T-amp many moons ago I mused about the possibility of someone taking the T-amp, reboxing it, adding a few shiny bits and selling it for 10000 Euro. Well I was right though they never went over 1000 Euro. Here I can imagine the same thing – rip out the fans and pro connectors, put a piano-black faceplate on it – throw in a couple of wonder caps and flog it for 2000 Euro. We'll see.
© Copyright 2012 Geoff Husband - email@example.com - www.tnt-audio.com